Small employers with no group health plan can provide a QSE-HRA to reimburse employees who obtain their own health insurance.
Introduction
The Health Reimbursement Arrangement (HRA) is a medical expense reimbursement plan funded by an employer for its employees. Reimbursements through an HRA are tax-deductible for the company and tax-exempt for employees.
HRAs have been popular with employers for decades. All of the costs were tax-deductible for employers and all
of the rules and plan options were decided by employers.
And, there was no interference from the government until 2002, when the IRS issued formal guidance in Notice 2002-45.
The Notice defined the HRA, in part, as an employer-provided arrangement which:
- Is paid for solely by the employer
- Is excluded from the employee’s gross income (tax-exempt),
- Reimburses the employee and dependents for medical care expenses,
- May only provide benefits that reimburse expenses for medical care as defined in § 213(d),
- Requires substantiation of each medical care expense submitted for reimbursement,
- Provides reimbursements up to a maximum dollar amount for a coverage period,
- Allows that unused balances at the end of the year may be carried into the following year,
- Is subject to HIPAA
privacy and COBRA continuation rules,
- Must be established with a written plan document and a copy of the plan document’s Summary Plan
Description given to every eligible participant.
New ACA rules
When the Affordable Care Act arrived, HRAs took a hit. Popular plans that employers had long used to
reimburse employees who bought their own health insurance were disallowed by the new law, and HRAs with a
group health plan could only offer plans that carry all the new ACA-required essential health benefits with
accompanying higher premiums.
A lot of employers lost their ability to provide an HRA to their employees on the same terms as before, while
others could no longer afford the new group health plans the ACA required. It was a hardship for many employers and employees alike.
ACA relief for small employers
Eventually, small employers found relief from the ACA through the Qualified Small Employer HRA. Legislated
through the 21st Century Cures Act of 2016, this ‘new’ HRA returns the ability for employers with fewer than
50 employees (and therefore not under the mandate) to once again provide a stand-alone HRA to reimburse
employees buying their own health insurance.
More HRA options for 2024
In October 2017, President Donald J. Trump issued Executive Order No. 13813, Presidential
Executive Order Promoting Healthcare Choice and Competition Across the United States. In
part, it instructs the Departments of Treasury and Health and Human Services, “to increase the usability of
HRAs, to expand employers’ ability to offer HRAs to their employees, and to allow HRAs to be used in
Less than two years later, in June, 2019, the President unveiled two new
HRAs to do just that.
Available for plan years beginning on January 1, 2020, or later, the Individual Coverage HRA allows employers of any size to offer an HRA
to reimburse individual health insurance premiums to employees and the Excepted
Benefit HRA is designed to accompany a group health plan but may be elected by employees whether or not they participate an employer’s group health insurance.
HRA vs. FSA
The main difference between the HRA and Health FSA is that the HRA is funded solely by the employer while the FSA
can be funded by both the employee and the employer.
Who funds the account determines how funds accrue and what happens with unused funds at the end of a plan year.
The FSA must be pre-funded. This means that when an employee elects to contribute $3,000 (through bi-weekly
pre-tax salary deductions of $100 throughout the year), the employer must make the entire $3,050 available
on day 1. This puts the employer at some risk of loss, though it is usually minimal.
With an HRA, the employer has the option to fund the account on a month-to-month basis. The employer also
decides what happens with unused HRA balances at the end of the year and can allow employees to roll
remaining funds over to the next plan year.
In contrast, an FSA, has a use-it-or-lose-it rule for balances that exceed the employer’s optional rollover
allowance (up to $640) or 75-day grace period.